FIRST Principles + founding sentence = good GOVERNANCE

Complain #8: Policy: Executive Order Removing National Monument Protections

FP and GPCN Numbers and Evaluation

9/23/20268 min read

First Principle Party Evaluation
Policy: Executive Order Removing National Monument Protections — President Trump's executive order reducing or eliminating protected status on approximately 3 million acres of national monument lands, reversing designations made by previous administrations under the Antiquities Act of 1906.

Step One — FP Factor

First principles at work:

Stewardship — A fundamental first principle governing the relationship between any generation and the natural resources it inherits is stewardship — the obligation to preserve and pass forward what was received. Land designated as having historic or scientific value represents a resource that belongs not just to the present generation but to all future generations. Stewardship requires that decisions about irreplaceable resources account for their long term value, not just their immediate use.

Intergenerational responsibility — The Preamble explicitly names posterity as a beneficiary of the mission. Irreplaceable natural and historic resources, once developed or degraded, cannot be restored to their previous condition. Decisions that permanently alter those resources impose consequences on future generations who have no voice in the current decision.

Precedent and rule of law — The Antiquities Act of 1906 has been used by presidents of both parties for over a century to protect lands with historic or scientific value. The act has never previously been used to remove protections once granted. Whether presidential authority extends to removal is a genuine and unsettled legal question currently before the courts. The principle that established law applies consistently regardless of who holds power is a first principle of functioning governance.

Concentrated benefit versus distributed cost — When public lands are opened to development, the benefits accrue primarily to the industries granted access while the costs — loss of ecosystem services, historic preservation, scientific research value, and public recreational access — are distributed across the entire public and across future generations. This asymmetry is a documented first principle of how resource extraction decisions operate when made without adequate public interest standards.

Irreversibility — Some decisions can be undone if they prove mistaken. The degradation or development of land with unique historic or scientific value cannot be fully undone. Irreversibility is a first principle that demands a higher standard of justification before action than reversible decisions require.

FP Factor: 5 first principles identified — stewardship, intergenerational responsibility, rule of law, concentrated benefit versus distributed cost, and irreversibility — all requiring honest examination before monument protections are removed.

Step Two — GPCN

1. Form a more perfect union: -45
National monuments represent shared public resources that belong to all Americans regardless of party, region, or economic status. Removing protections from lands designated for their historic and scientific value — lands that often hold special significance for Indigenous communities, outdoor recreation communities, and scientific researchers — does not form a more perfect union. It transfers shared public resources to the benefit of specific economic interests while imposing the costs of that transfer on the general public. The legal challenge already filed by multiple states further deepens the division rather than resolving it.

2. Establish justice: -50
Justice requires that public resources held in trust for all citizens be managed according to consistent, transparent, and publicly accountable standards. The removal of monument protections that have been in place for years — in some cases decades — without clear evidence that the original designation was improper raises legitimate questions about whether the decision serves the public interest or the interests of industries seeking access to those lands. The legal question of whether presidential authority even extends to removing Antiquities Act protections is unresolved, meaning the action may itself lack legal authorization — a direct justice concern.

3. Ensure domestic tranquility: -40
The removal of protections from nationally significant lands has generated immediate and documented public opposition across multiple states, from conservation organizations, Indigenous communities, scientific bodies, and recreational users. The resulting legal challenges, public protests, and interstate conflict represent a documented disruption to domestic tranquility that serves no demonstrated offsetting benefit to the general public.

4. Provide for the common defense: -5
No significant direct connection to defense. A modest negative score reflects the documented value of protected lands to military training operations and the general principle that a nation's natural and historic heritage contributes to the cultural identity and resilience that underlie long term national security.

5. Promote the general welfare: -65
The general welfare of the American people includes access to shared natural and historic resources, the ecosystem services those resources provide, the scientific knowledge they enable, and the recreational, cultural, and spiritual value they hold for millions of citizens. Removing protection from 3 million acres of land designated for its historic and scientific value does not promote the general welfare of the whole people. It promotes the economic interests of the industries that gain access to those lands — a documented subset of the population — while imposing costs on the general welfare of the whole.

The intergenerational dimension compounds the welfare failure. Future generations — explicitly named in the Preamble as beneficiaries of the mission — have no voice in a decision that permanently alters resources they will inherit.

6. Liberty achieved — average of first five: -41

Overall GPCN Score: -41

Determination: FAIL

The executive order removing national monument protections fails the Preamble test most severely on the general welfare goal — because general welfare is the goal most directly betrayed when irreplaceable public resources held in trust for all Americans and their posterity are made available to private economic interests without demonstrated public benefit.

This determination does not resolve the legal question of whether the president has authority under the Antiquities Act to remove monument designations — that question is before the courts and this evaluation does not substitute for judicial review. It asks a different and prior question: does this action serve the mission the American people authorized?

The documented answer is no. The action concentrates its benefits in a narrow set of economic interests while distributing its costs — loss of protected historic and scientific resources, legal conflict, public opposition, and intergenerational harm — across the whole people and their posterity.

The Preamble does not authorize the transfer of shared public resources to private interests. It authorizes the promotion of the general welfare of the whole people — including those not yet born who will inherit whatever this generation chooses to preserve or destroy.

GPCN: -41 | FP Factor: 5 first principles identified, all requiring honest examination before irreplaceable public resources are permanently altered | DETERMINATION: FAIL

National Monument Lands: The Remedy's Projected GPCN

Result

The remedy lifts national monument lands from a GPCN of −41 (FAIL) to a projected +35 (PASS). It does not settle who holds the legal authority over monument designations, which is for the courts and Congress. It changes how any decision about protected lands is made: measured against the mission, held to a higher standard when it cannot be undone, shown with who gains and who pays, and counted for those not yet born. These are projections of what the remedy would do if adopted, not measurements.

The remedy

The party supports one policy in four parts: changes to protected lands are measured against the mission, held to a higher bar when they cannot be undone, shown with who gains and who pays, and counted for posterity.

  1. Measure every change against the six goals. Before any monument or protected designation is reduced, removed or opened to development, a GPCN is published, as the Founding Sentence Enforcement Act provides. A change that fails the test has to be justified in public or dropped.

  2. Set a higher bar for what cannot be undone. A change that permanently alters land of historic or scientific value needs a public hearing and approval by Congress. Congress also settles in statute whether designations may be removed, so protection and removal follow one written rule and not a series of reversals.

  3. Show who gains and who pays. For every parcel opened to use, the public record names the interests granted access, the public value given up, and the campaign contributions and lobbying ties linked to the officials who approved it.

  4. Count the future. Before any change, the land's condition and value are surveyed and published, with a statement of what posterity inherits if the change goes ahead and what it loses.

Step One: FP Factor

Five first principles bear on this remedy, and all five support it.

  • Stewardship. Each generation owes the next what it received. A published survey and a GPCN before any change put long-term value ahead of immediate use.

  • Intergenerational responsibility. The Preamble names posterity, which has no vote. The statement of what posterity inherits gives it a place in the decision.

  • Precedent and rule of law. Established law applies the same way whoever holds power. Congress settling the removal question in statute replaces reversals with one written rule.

  • Concentrated benefit versus distributed cost. Naming the interests granted access and the public value given up shows the asymmetry before the decision is made.

  • Irreversibility. What cannot be undone needs a higher standard of justification. A public hearing and approval by Congress set that standard.

FP Factor: 5 first principles identified, all supporting the remedy.

Step two: GPCN by goal

Welfare gains the most, because the remedy weighs shared resources and posterity before any change. Defense gains least, since its link to monument lands is slight.

Why each number

Each goal is shown as today's number, then the projected number if the remedy is adopted.

  1. Form a more perfect union: −45 to +35. Monuments are shared resources that belong to all Americans. A public record of who gains and who pays, and one written rule for removal, ends the pattern of reversals that deepens division. The gain is held back because the dispute between states and the federal government does not end the day a rule is adopted.

  2. Establish justice: −50 to +50. Public land held in trust is managed by consistent, transparent and accountable standards, and the authority question is settled by Congress and not left to successive orders. The gain is held back because enforcement has to prove itself.

  3. Ensure domestic tranquility: −40 to +30. A hearing, a published GPCN and a settled rule give those with a stake a process and not a fight in court. The gain is moderate because some interests will still lose.

  4. Provide for the common defense: −5 to +10. The connection to defense is slight. The small gain reflects that protected lands keep their value for military training and for the heritage that underlies resilience.

  5. Promote the general welfare: −65 to +50. This is the largest gain. Shared natural and historic resources, the ecosystem services and research value they hold, and the access of millions of citizens are weighed before any change, and posterity is counted. It stays at +50 because some development in the public interest remains possible.

  6. Liberty achieved, the average of the five: −41 to +35. Liberty is what the first five goals produce together.

Determination

GPCN: +35 | FP Factor: 5 first principles identified, all supporting the remedy | DETERMINATION: PASS

What this does not claim

  • These are projections, not measurements. They show what the party expects if the remedy is adopted, reasoned goal by goal above.

  • It does not settle the legal question. Whether a president may remove a monument designation is before the courts. The remedy asks Congress to answer it in statute and leaves the courts to decide the case in front of them.

  • It does not say all development is wrong. Some uses of public land may serve the six goals. The remedy requires that each be measured, shown in public, and held to a higher bar if it cannot be undone.

  • It does not say which lands should be protected. Congress and the public still decide. The remedy sets how the decision is made.

  • What would lower the number. A hearing requirement with no real weight would lose most of the justice gain, and a survey that is never published would lose the stewardship gain.

  • You can challenge it. If you think a number is wrong, propose a different one with your reasoning on the party's website.

Contact

Questions or comments? Reach out anytime.

Our Email

Connect

michael3h@zoho.com

© 2026. All rights reserved.